How to Analyze 1031 Exchanges in a Foreclosure Situation Montrose CO

Some investors are faced with the prospect of a short sale, or a lender’s foreclosure. The investors in this situation have a multitude of concerns ranging from the loss of the equity invested in their property to a reduced credit rating. Unfortunately, there is often another consequence: the short sale or lender’s foreclosure can sometimes result in an income tax gain that must be recognized.
Douglas Wayne Brown
303-329-3363
2000 S COLORADO BLVD COLORADO CTR
DENVER, CO
Dewayne Gooch
(719) 636-0001
2532 W. Colorado Ave
Colorado Springs, CO
Richard N Gonzales
303-839-8888
12110 PECOS ST STE 240
DENVER, CO
Thomas M. Mathiowetz
(303) 756-1500
3801 East Florida Avenue
Denver, CO
Andrew Mclure Toft
303-436-0980
216 16TH ST STE 1210
DENVER, CO
Robert J. Doig
(719) 302-4252
624 South Cascade Avenue
Colorado Springs, CO
Jacquelyn R Wayne
303-629-5200
3500 Republic Plaza, 370 17th Street
Denver, CO
Michael Robinson
(303) 688-0944
757 Meleta Lane
Castle Rock, CO
Ronald Scott Fitzke
303-694-2000
4 INVERNESS CT E STE 100
ENGLEWOOD, CO
Justin Haenlein
(719) 277-6602
1155 Kelly Johnson Blvd.
Colorado Springs, CO
Data Provided by:
  

How to Analyze 1031 Exchanges in a Foreclosure Situation

Some investors are faced with the prospect of a short sale, or a lender’s foreclosure. The investors in this situation have a multitude of concerns ranging from the loss of the equity invested in their property to a reduced credit rating. Unfortunately, there is often another consequence: the short sale or lender’s foreclosure can sometimes result in an income tax gain that must be recognized. This is especially true where the investment property was originally acquired in a §1031 tax deferred exchange.

 
A gain for tax purposes would occur in the context of a short sale or foreclosure, if the mortgage debt encumbering the property is greater than the taxpayer’s adjusted basis for income tax purposes. This happens because the transfer of the property to the lender is treated in part as if the investment property is sold to the lender for its fair market value. The determination of how much gain is recognized, and the character of the gain in this context, depends on whether the mortgage debt is recourse (e.g., a loan for which the borrower is personally liable) or nonrecourse (e.g., a loan for which the borrower is not personally liable). If the mortgage secures a recourse loan, the investor is treated for income tax purposes as: (i) having cancellation of indebtedness income to the extent that the mortgage debt exceeds the fair market value of the property and (ii) a capital gain or loss equal to the difference between the actual value of the property and the taxpayer’s adjusted basis for income tax purposes. In the case of a nonrecourse loan, the investor recognizes a capital gain equal to the difference between the mortgage debt and the investor’s basis in the property. In a nonrecourse analysis, the fair market value of the property is treated as not less than the nonrecourse debt.
 
As previously mentioned, the tax consequences of a short sale or foreclosure are often considered only after the property is gone and the dust has settled. As it turns out, a savvy investor may be able to defer the gain resulting from the short sale or foreclosure. For example, the cash that would otherwise be needed to pay the tax liability could be used to acquire replacement property in a §1031 tax deferred exchange. For practical reasons, this option will not be available to all of the investors, but in some cases it works beautifully. The following is an example of how some taxpayers are using this strategy in a fractional ownership foreclosure:
 
The investor completes a tax deferred exchange in which a tenant-in-common interest in commercial real property (TIC interest) is acquired. The TIC interest is managed under a master lease under which the investor receives a percentage of the net rent received by the master lessee on the property. The investor’s “exchange basis” in the TIC interest is $70. The TIC interest is originally acquired with a value of $200 and secures an...

Click here to read the rest of this article from NuWire Investor